Swindell,Frankfurt, and ambivalence |
| |
Authors: | David Svolba |
| |
Affiliation: | 1. Department of Philosophy , University of Illinois at Chicago , Chicago, USA dsvolba@yahoo.com |
| |
Abstract: | J.S. Swindell has argued that Harry Frankfurt's analysis of ambivalence is ambiguous and that it fails to do justice to the full range of this psychological phenomenon. Building on her criticism of Frankfurt, Swindell offers an analysis of ambivalence which is supposed to clarify ambiguities in Frankfurt's analysis and reveal varieties of ambivalence that Frankfurt's analysis allegedly overlooks. In this brief reply, I argue that Frankfurt's analysis of ambivalence is neither ambiguous nor objectionably narrow. I conclude with remarks on Swindell's analysis of the relationship between ambivalence and weakness of the will. |
| |
Keywords: | Frankfurt ambivalence identification Swindell weakness of will |
|
|