Human search procedures and the use of expert systems |
| |
Authors: | Dianne C Berry and Donald E Broadbent |
| |
Institution: | (1) Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, OX1 3UD Oxford, U.K. |
| |
Abstract: | Four experiments are reported. These experiments compare the effects of two different forms of machine advice on performance
on a complex search task. The task involves determining which of a set of factories is responsible for polluting a river by
testing the river for the presence or absence of various pollutants. Subjects either receive a suggestion as to which pollutant
they should test for on each go, or following testing for a pollutant they are told which of the factories could possibly
be polluting the river at that stage, or they receive a combination of the two forms of advice. The experiments show that
suggesting to subjects which pollutant they should test for on each go is of no benefit, whereas providing a list of possible
factory names after testing for each pollutant significantly benefits performance. Only subjects who receive both types of
advice simultaneously, however, maintain an improved performance level when the advice is withdrawn.
This research was supported by the Alvey Directorate. Mr. E.C. Portman of ICL, West Gorton, acted as “industrial uncle” to
the project. |
| |
Keywords: | |
本文献已被 SpringerLink 等数据库收录! |
|