Decision making and memory: a critique of Juslin and Olsson's (1997) sampling model of sensory discrimination. |
| |
Authors: | D Vickers A Pietsch |
| |
Institution: | Department of Psychology, Adelaide University, Adelaide, South Australia 5005, Australia. douglas.vickers@adelaide.edu.au |
| |
Abstract: | P. Juslin and H. Olsson's (1997) distinction between Thurstonian and Brunswikian uncertainty is examined and their sampling model of sensory discrimination analyzed as a representative of the class of memoryless decision processes. The separate characteristics and combined behavior of 4 main components of the model are explored: (a) the basic decision process, (b) the assumption of deadline responding, (c) the moving window model of memory, and (d) the hypothesized basis for confidence. It is argued that grafting a moving window memory onto a memoryless decision process has several undesirable consequences. Moreover, the suggested basis for confidence leads to predictions that are counterintuitive and unsupported by empirical evidence. It is concluded that the window-sampling model is a maladapted combination of inappropriate elements, which is implausible as a model of decision making, memory, or confidence, in sensory discrimination. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|