Defending Evidence‐Resistant Beliefs |
| |
Authors: | Nikolai Viedge |
| |
Affiliation: | Department of PhilosophyUniversity of Johannesburg |
| |
Abstract: | There is a view in the literature around beliefs that evidence responsiveness is a necessary feature of beliefs. The reasoning is that because beliefs are governed by truth they must be evidence responsive. A mental state that fails to be evidence responsive, therefore, could not be a belief as it could not be governed by truth. The implication is that even those evidence‐resistant mental states that appear to be beliefs are in fact something else. I argue that evidence resistance is a feature of at least some beliefs, so evidence responsiveness cannot be a necessary feature of belief. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|