PRINZ'S PROBLEMATIC PROXYTYPES |
| |
Authors: | Raffaella De Rosa |
| |
Affiliation: | Rutgers University at Newark, New Jersey |
| |
Abstract: | Jesse Prinz has argued that a proxy type theory of concepts provides what he calls the 'intentionality' and 'cognitive content' desiderata better than any current competitor, and that the hybrid nature of proxytypes allows his theory to combine the informational component of informational atomism with the view that concepts are semantically structured entities. In response, I argue that the hybrid character of proxytypes, far from delivering the advantages Prinz claims, generates a threatening dilemma: either his theory is novel but fails to deliver the intentionality and cognitive content desiderata, or it delivers these desiderata but is not novel. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|