Diagnosis and treatment of respiratory tract infections in primary health care by the nurse versus the physician: Efficacy and patient attitudes

Abstract

Five district physicians and one registered nurse were compared regarding their effectiveness in diagnosing and treating acute upper respiratory tract infections in patients (n=186) at a Swedish community health centre. Attitudes and views of the patient, or of the accompanying adult when the patient was a child, regarding the consultation itself, as well as more general aspects of health care were investigated (n=99) using a questionnaire. The questionnaire included 42 propositions of a “fuzzy” type to be judged on a 100-point truth-value scale, 18 of them concerning the consultation and 24 the more general aspects. No differences between the physicians and the nurse were found in their efficacy of diagosis and treatment. Subjects' overall attitudes were found to be positive toward both the physicians and the nurse. Results of multivariate analyses of variance performed for the consultation and general aspects of health care items separately and concerning type of persons providing health care (physician/nurse), treatment (antibiotics/no antibiotics) and patient age (child/adult), revealed overall differences in questionnaire response as regards patient age in relation to the consultation items.