On sensitive rank tests for comparing the effects of two treatments on a single group

The rank testR_n of Cronholm and Revusky [1965] in effect doubles the number of comparisons carried out in the Mann-Whitney test between Treated and Control subjects chosen from a single group ofn and triples the asymptotic Pitman efficiency against shift alternatives by using a series ofn — 1 subexperiments. However, the full series can be too costly or time-consuming. It is shown thatj appropriately chosen subexperiments will permit one to make at leastj/(j+1) of the number of comparisons possible underR_n, with large sample efficiency ofj/(j+2) relative toR_n against shift alternatives and small sample efficiency greater than that,j=2, 3, ...,n — 2. The resulting test criterion is a sum ofj independent Mann-Whitney test statistics. Its null distribution is tabulated forn10 and small sample efficiency comparisons are carried out forn=10.