SOSA'S MOORE AND THE NEW DOGMATISTS |
| |
Authors: | SUSANA NUCCETELLI |
| |
Institution: | Department of Philosophy, CH 265, St. Cloud State University, St. Cloud, MN 56301, USA
|
| |
Abstract: | Abstract: Some seventy years ago, G. E. Moore invoked his own sensory experience (as of a hand before him in the right circumstances), added some philosophical analysis about externality, and took himself to have offered his "Proof" of the existence of an external world. Current neo-Mooreans either reject completely the standard negative assessment of the Proof or qualify it substantially. For Sosa, the Proof can be persuasive, but only when read literally as offering reasons for the conclusion that there is at least one external object—rather than that the prover is justified in believing, or even knowing, that there is at least one external object. Sosa, then, is a neo-Moorean—though not of the sort we might expect in light of the ongoing debate about the Proof. I argue that Sosa needs to say more about the circularity often thought to vitiate the Proof before we can accept his view. |
| |
Keywords: | begging the question transmission of warrant Moore's Proof neo-Mooreanism skepticism idealism |
|
|