“Bipolar groupthink”: Assessing groupthink tendencies in authentic work groups |
| |
Authors: | Michael Rosander Dan Stiwne Kjell Granstr
M |
| |
Institution: | Michael Rosander,Dan Stiwne,Kjell GranstrÖM |
| |
Abstract: | Research on regressive group processes such as Janis’ (1982) “groupthink” phenomenon has rarely focused on work groups in authentic settings. In this study, teams from six different organisations (n=308) were studied by using a groupthink questionnaire constructed in accordance with the symptoms of groupthink described by Janis. It was hypothesised that groupthink could be described as a bipolar construct identifying either an omnipotent or a depressive variant of a group’s delusions about its own and other groups’ features. The questionnaire showed reasonably good reliability as a whole and a factor analysis identified three factors in line with the proposed theoretical model in which the two different types of groupthink can be distinguished. We propose that any group might have a tendency or predisposition to react in either of the two directions during provocative circumstances. The six different organisations exhibited different types of groupthink to a varying degree. A religious sect was the one most characterised by omnipotent groupthink, while a technological company and a psychiatric team seemed to be the ones with most features of depressive groupthink. |
| |
Keywords: | Groupthink group processes bipolar groupthink |
|