The perception of pure and mistuned musical fifths and major thirds: Thresholds for discrimination,beats, and identification

In Experiment 1, the discriminability of pure and mistuned musical intervals consisting of simultaneously presented complex tones was investigated. Because of the interference of nearby harmonics, two features of beats were varied independently: (1) beat frequency, and (2) the depth of the level variation. Discrimination thresholds (DTs) were expressed as differences in level (AL) between the two tones. DTs were determined for musical fifths and major thirds, at tone durations of 250, 500, and 1,000 msec, and for beat frequencies within a range of .5 to 32 Hz. The results showed that DTs were higher (smaller values of ΔL) for major thirds than for fifths, were highest for the lowest beat frequencies, and decreased with increasing tone duration. Interaction of tone duration and beat frequency showed that DTs were higher for short tones than for sustained tones only when the mistuning was not too large. It was concluded that, at higher beat frequencies, DTs could be based more on the perception of interval width than on the perception of beats or roughness. Experiments 2 and 3 were designed to ascertain to what extent this was true. In Experiment 2, beat thresholds (BTs) for a large number of different beat frequencies were determined. In Experiment 3, DTs, BTs, and thresholds for the identification of the direction of mistuning (ITs) were determined. For mistuned fifths and major thirds, sensitivity to beats was about the same. ITs for fifths and major thirds were not significantly different; deviations from perfect at threshold ranged from about 20 to 30 cents. Comparison of the different thresholds revealed that DTs are mainly determined by sensitivity to beats. Detailed analysis, however, indicated that perception of interval width is a relevant aspect in discrimination, especially for the fifths.