Empathy and evaluation: Understanding the private meanings of behavior |
| |
Authors: | H A Alexander |
| |
Institution: | (1) The University of Judaism, Mulholland Drive, 90054 Los Angeles, CA |
| |
Abstract: | This paper makes three points. First, empathy cannot be considered an epistemic basis for qualitative research and evaluation. Second, it is, however, a valuable method for understanding the private meanings of words and deeds. Third, this method is not completely reliable for purposes of what Popper called refutation, but is useful in what he dubbed scientific conjecture or the generation of theory. Basic researchers will need to take the necessary steps to subject empathetic hunches to critical examination. However, owing to the exigencies of action settings and decision-making, disciplined conjectures are sometimes the most that evaluators can hope to record.An earlier version of this paper was printed in the Proceedings of the Far Western Philosophy of Education Society, 1989. This version is published with permission of the Far Western Philosophy of Education society. The author is grateful for helpful comments and critisism made by members of the California Association for Philosophy Education. Remaining errors, of course, are the authors responsibility alone. |
| |
Keywords: | empathy evaluation qualitative inquiry understanding verstehen |
本文献已被 SpringerLink 等数据库收录! |
|