Comments on Shimp's (1983) double dissociation between knowledge and tacit knowledge

Shimp (1983) found in five pigeons “double dissociation” between the distribution of pairs of long and short reinforced interresponse times and “self-reports,” obtained by symbolic matching to sample, concerning these interresponse times. This result can be explained by assuming that the birds used a fixed temporal interval as matching criterion, independently of which pattern of interresponse times was reinforced.     

SOCIAL-SKILLS TRAINING TO MODIFY ABUSIVE VERBAL OUTBURSTS IN ADULTS

Social-skills training was used to modify abusive verbal outbursts displayed by two adult psychiatric patients. Five target behaviors—looking, irrelevant comments, hostile comments, inappropriate requests, and appropriate requests were monitored during role-played situations. Social-skills training, consisting of behavior rehearsal with modelling, focused instructions, and feedback, was introduced in a multiple-baseline design across individuals. Training improved all target behaviors. The improved behavior generalized to: (1) novel scenes role-played with the original respondent, (2) training and novel scenes role-played with a different respondent, and (3) interpersonal situations on the hospital ward.     

Relative attention in judgments of heterogeneous similarity

Shepard’s (1964) study on similarity of stimuli with clearly discernible dimensions was repeated with some modifications, the most important being that the Os had to make numerical similarity estimates of the stimulus pairs. The overall outcome did not deviate much from Shepard’s findings. By using quantitative estimates and choosing stimulus series so that the two dimensions were negatively correlated, data for each 0 could be analyzed separately with a partial correlation technique. It was found that the more an 0 attended to one dimension the less he attended to the other. The shifts in attention seemed to be random rather than regular. Consequently, the meaningfulness of a contention like Shepard’s as to the nonexistence of a metric is questioned.     

Applicability of the parallel-clock model to duration discrimination

The parallel-clock model assumes that when an observer is presented with two durations in succession, the total subjective duration (corresponding to the sum of first and second durations) and the second duration are each accumulated in a separate sensory register. In dealing with some relation between the two durations, the observer compares the difference between the contents of the two registers with the contents of the second register. With the further assumption that the psychophysical power law is valid for the continuum of time, the model has previously been shown to account well for duration scaling data. After adapting the model in the vein of Thurstone for duration discrimination data, it was tried out on such data gathered by Allan (1977) from 13 observers. With chi-square as the examined statistic, (1) five distributions were compared and the normal one chosen, (2) one categorization model, three choice models, and two linear regression models were compared with the 3-parameter version of the parallel-lock model, which proved superior, and (3) a 4–5-parameter version of the parallel-clock model, assuming a discontinuity in the psychophysical function, was shown to yield an excellent fit in terms of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic.     

A retrospective analysis of alcohol consumption on laboratory tasks as related to therapeutic outcome

The relationship between drinking on laboratory-analogue measures at the onset of inpatient alcoholism treatment and abstinence subsequent to treatment was examined. Twenty therapeutically successful and 20 unsuccessful chronic alcoholics were selected and did not differ on age, education, length of problem drinking, and length of follow-up. Retrospective analysis of responding on an operant drinking task and a ‘taste test’ assessment technique revealed significant differences between the groups, with successful patients drinking less than the unsuccessful ones. Implications for screening candidates for alcoholism treatment programs are discussed.     

Is an equal interval scale an equal discriminability scale?

Stevens and Galanter’s (1957) iterative procedure for minimizing bias in category scaling was used for the scaling of loudness of white noise. The spacing obtained deviated systematically from a spacing constructed in accordance with an equal discriminability scale from a previous experiment (Eisler & Montgomery, 1972). For the stimulus spacing yielding a “pure” category scale, a magnitude scale was constructed too. Since the category scale could be predicted accurately by Fechnerian integration of this magnitude scale, it was concluded that the “pure” category scale is a pure discrimination scale. The discrepancy between the equal discriminability scale and the “pure” category scale was interpreted as a bias in the former scale due to greater recognizability of stimuli located at the extremes of the stimulus range.     

A GENERAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION IN PSYCHO-PHYSICS: DERIVATION AND EMPIRICAL TEST

By a reasoning similar to Fechner's a general psychophysical differential equation is developed. Its integration allows the calculation of intrasubjective relations, provided the Weber functions of the two pertinent variables are known. The method is empirically validated for the relation between category and magnitude scales and for the similarity function. Theoretical implications are discussed.