类比迁移研究综述

该文在介绍类比迁移的概念、阶段、影响类比迁移的因素,以及研究类比迁移的意义的基础上,主要介绍了类比迁移的三个重要理论：结构映射理论、实用图式和示例理论,并对其进行简单的评价。     

儿童问题解决中的类比迁移

儿童问题解决中的类比迁移是儿童认知发展中的一个基本问题,但在儿童发展研究中却一直没有得到足够的重视。在对儿童问题解决中的类比迁移研究进行回顾和总结的基础上,特别是仔细分析最近十年里的类比迁移研究,该文总结出了儿童问题解决中类比迁移研究的发展趋势,主要包括从探讨迁移是否存在到验证迁移是一种早期能力、从关注迁移的年龄差异到关注促进迁移的有关因素、从关注迁移是否是基本能力到关注迁移的加工机制、从描述迁移技能到领域概化、从关注近迁移到关注远迁移。最后,该文对未来儿童问题解决中的类比迁移研究进行了展望     

类比迁移研究综述

该文在介绍类比迁移的概念、阶段、影响类比迁移的因素 ,以及研究类比迁移的意义的基础上 ,主要介绍了类比迁移的三个重要理论 :结构映射理论、实用图式和示例理论 ,并对其进行简单的评价     

数学问题类比迁移的影响因素研究

类比迁移在人类的学习中有着不可替代的地位,但学科问题类比迁移的相关研究仍不充足。本文以数学问题解决为研究对象,探讨了数学问题类比迁移的影响因素。实验研究了问题相似性、被试特点(年级、元认知监控)对数学问题类比迁移的影响。实验结果表明:源靶问题间的表面相似性是影响类比迁移的主要因素,它既促进正迁移,也容易导致负迁移;不同年级被试解决数学问题成绩差异显著;被试在解决数学问题时的实时元认知监控与该问题的解决相关显著。     

类比迁移发生机制的研究

本研究包含两个实验,探讨类比迁移发生的机制。实验一主要探索类比迁移中的图式归纳是一种自动加工还是控制加工。实验二主要探索类比迁移中的图式归纳是保留性的还是排除性的。本实验结果表明,类比迁移中的图式归纳主要是控制加工,是一种保留性的归纳。     

目标启动对类比问题解决策略迁移的影响

运用实验法和问卷法对小学2年级和5年级学生的类比问题解决策略的迁移进行了研究。结果表明:无论儿童年龄大小,启动掌握目标都可以有效地促进类比问题解决策略的迁移。能力知觉与回避型表现目标存在交互作用,在回避型表现目标启动条件下,能力知觉低的儿童迁移成绩较差。儿童自身的成就目标取向未对迁移产生影响。     

规则形式及其呈现问题情境对高二学生类比迁移影响研究

本研究以396名高中二年级学生为被试,采用4×4组间设计探讨规则形式及其呈现问题情境对类比迁移的影响。主要得到以下结论:1.在类比迁移中起关键作用的是规则,但是规则只有与样例结合才能发挥它对样例的促进作用;2.在有问题情境时,直接呈现规则与需要归纳才能得到规则相比,更有利于促进类比迁移;3.在有规则的情况下,样例间的关系为不同领域的相似关系与其他样例间关系相比,对类比迁移的促进作用更大。     

类比比较样例对物理综合题学习迁移效果的影响

研究通过三个实验,比较了普通样例和类比比较样例在学习物理综合题中的效果,并在此基础上,进一步分析两种不同类型的类比比较样例对物理综合题学习的迁移效果以及“提示”这一样例设计方法的促进作用。结果发现:(1)通过类比比较样例学习物理综合题的效果优于普通样例;(2)相比于单综概念类比比较样例,综合概念类比比较样例能更好地提高物理综合题学习的近迁移成绩,但未提高其远迁移成绩;(3)提示能明显促进类比比较样例在物理综合题学习中的作用,但不同提示类型的影响无显著差异。该结果表明:类比比较样例是学习物理综合题的有效样例形式,而其中综合概念类比比较样例效果最佳;开放式提示和支架式提示均能较好地促进类比比较样例的学习。     

定势对程序性知识学习迁移的影响

以较为复杂的课堂学习材料为对象,研究定势对程序性知识学习迁移的影响。结果表明:1.程序性知识的学习迁移中有定势负效应;重视样例的条件结构,构建起条件原型的学习准备状态,将有助于知识迁移;2.具备条件认知学习状态的被试,不仅顺利完成表面形式的迁移,而且在内在结构的迁移中,能突破表面形式的干扰,表现出较好的内在结构迁移成绩;3.结构类比要比仅仅进行特征类比产生更大的迁移效果。     

内容因素对文章结构映射迁移效果影响的实验研究

１问题Ｇｅｎｔｎｅｒ于１９８３年提出类比产生的结构映射理论（ｓｔｒｕｃｔｕｒｅｍａｐｐｉｎｇ　ｔｈｅｏｒｙ）．认为类比是知识从一个领域（源领域）向另一个领域（目标领域）的映射。该理论提出两个重要原理：第一是系统性原理。它指明了类比实现的基本条件。根据系统性原理,类比只映射关系不映射属性。第二个原理是透明度原理。它指明了影响类比实现的因素。根据透明度原理,结构对应的两事物如果结构清晰,或者其要素之间也存在有形的匹配．则透明度高．容易产生类比映射。关于类比迁移的研究已经成为当前迁移研究的重点。然而,…     

Problem solving,recall, and isomorphic transfer among third-grade and sixth-grade children

Analogical reasoning processes were studied in third- and sixth-grade children. One group at each grade level received two analogs of the “farmer's dilemma”, a scheduling problem that requires seven moves for solution, during acquisition. Other groups received one analog or only a transfer task. On each trial the child heard a list of statements representing the exact series of moves necessary to solve the problem, was immediately asked to recall the list, materials representing the problem were then produced, and the child was asked to show how to solve it. A trial was terminated and a new one begun when an error was made on the physical task. Following criterial performance all children were transferred to an isomorphic analog and simply instructed to solve it. Third-graders in the two-analog condition required more trials in acquisition than the other groups, which did not differ from each other. Transfer was better following two analogs, but was unaffected by grade level. Grade level affected recall accuracy, but recall accuracy was not a good predictor of transfer performance. Trial-by-trial analyses suggested that propositions representing the solution are acquired piecemeal, but consolidation of the generalizable problem representation is abrupt.     

Testing and Training Analogical Responding in Young Children Using A Relational Evaluation Procedure

The Psychological Record - Analogical responding, or relating relations, as operationally defined by relational frame theory (RFT), is ubiquitous in everyday language and cognition, and is a key...     

Testing and Training Analogical Relational Responding in Children With and Without Autism

The Psychological Record - Analogical responding is ubiquitous in everyday language and cognition and is a key component in learning. However, there is relatively little behavioral research on...     

Predicting Naming Latencies with an Analogical Model

Skousen's (1989, Analogical modeling of language, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht) Analogical Model (AM) predicts behavior such as spelling pronunciation by comparing the characteristics of a test item (a given input word) to those of individual exemplars in a data set of previously encountered items. While AM and other exemplar-based models enjoy continuing success in their ability to predict what a participant's response to a given task will be, it does not yet include a widely tested mechanism for extending its predictions to other measures of interest in psycholinguistics such as response time (RT). This article reports the results of applying a formula derived in Estes (1959, in: Koch, Psychology: A study of a science, McGraw-Hill Book Co., Inc.) for approximating "mean predicted latency" in decision tasks to the alternative responses and their associated probabilities predicted by AM. The model is tested against six sets of data from previously published naming studies.     

Domain transfer via cross-domain analogy

Analogical learning has long been seen as a powerful way of extending the reach of one’s knowledge. We present the domain transfer via analogy (DTA) method for learning new domain theories via cross-domain analogy. Our model uses analogies between pairs of textbook example problems, or worked solutions, to create a domain mapping between a familiar and a new domain. This mapping allows us to initialize a new domain theory. After this initialization, another analogy is made between the domain theories themselves, providing additional conjectures about the new domain. We present two experiments in which our model learns rotational kinematics by an analogy with translational kinematics, and vice versa. These learning rates outperform those from a version of the system that is incrementally given the correct domain theory.     

基于问题解决式的类比推理的老化：表面相似性和结构相似性的作用

采用2年龄(老年/年轻)×2表面相似性(高/低)×2结构相似性(高/低)三因素混合设计, 考察表面信息和结构信息在基于问题解决范式的类比推理老化中的作用。结果发现, 老年人的类比推理成绩显著差于年轻人。源问题和靶问题的表面相似性和结构相似性的提高, 会促进个体检索源问题, 并提高推理质量。对于老年人而言, 表面相似性更重要; 对于年轻人而言, 结构相似性更重要。     

The Analogical Argument for Animal Pain

Philosophical defenders of animal liberation believe that we have direct duties to animals. Typically a presumption of that belief is that animals have the capacity to experience pain and suffering. Notoriously, however, a strand of Western scientific and philosophical thought has held animals to be incapable of experiencing pain, and even today one frequently encounters in discussions of animal liberation expressions of scepticism about whether animals really experience pain.
The Analogical Argument for Animal Pain responds to this scepticism by claiming that it is just as reasonable for me to believe that animals feel pain, given my only evidence for this is shared behaviour and physiology, as it is for me to believe that other humans feel pain on the basis of similar evidence. In this paper I expound and defend this Argument.     

Reviews

Book reviewed in this article:
The Spiritual Nature of Man. By A lister H ardy .
The Analogical Imagination: Christian Theology and the Culture. of Pluralism. By DAVID TRACY.
The Texture of Know1edge: An Essay on Religion and Science. By J ames W. J ones .     

Analogical modification in the creation of contemporary art

The goal of this study was to propose a framework to describe the analogical process in the context of creation. We conducted retrospective interviews with two contemporary artists in their forties using portfolios of their past works so that they could recall their creation processes in detail. We found that the artists often use analogical modification to produce new series of artwork. Analogical modification is a cognitive process used to generate a new target, in the context of creation, by changing values of a source to make differences during analogical mapping. We found three types of analogical modification, namely, subject modification, structure modification, and concept modification. Creative vision, which is formed through many years of creative activity and consists of long-term intentions or goals for creation, plays an important role in guiding the use of analogical modification. The process of artistic creation can be better understood using the framework of the interaction between activities in different time spans, such as analogical modification and creative vision.     

Awakening from Descartes' nightmare: On the love of ambiguity in phenomenological approaches to education

This paper is an exploration of the Cartesian paradigms of clarity and univocity and how these inform contemporary educational theory and practice. Phenomenology is discussed as a way of disrupting Descartes' visions of clarity and distinctness as paradigms of knowledge and as a return of inquiry to life as it is actually lived. Analogical discourse is examined as a way of giving a voice to this sort of inquiry. Heidegger's notions of inquiry as obedience and thanksgiving are discussed.