Review Essay: Constructivism with a Human Face

Irwin Hoffman's book Ritual and Spontaneity includes, but goes well beyond, his series of seminal papers—written over the past several decades—developing a psychoanalytic, constructivist perspective. A new, existential framework depicts what Hoffman calls the “psychobiological bedrock” at the core of the human process of constructing meaning—the lifelong effort to create a livable, subjective world in face of our ever present sense of loss, suffering, and, ultimately, mortality.

This review describes Hoffman's encompassing, existential perspective and discusses how, within this framework, he uses his dialectical sensibility to frame our understanding of both parenting and analysis as “semisacred” activities. The “dialectic of ritual and spontaneity”—the vital clash between disciplined adherence to the analytic frame and personally expressive deviations from it—represents the creative tension between the “magical” dimension of analytic authority and the healing influence of a genuinely expressive human relationship. Hoffman's perspective on the self-interested, “dark side” of the analytic relationship is compared with Winnicott's views on the vital, therapeutic role of “hate” and the paradoxical process by which the patient comes to “use” the analyst.

Unlike most postmodernist “constructivists,” Hoffman openly reveals his underlying belief in certain “transcultural, transhistorical universals”—his “psychobiological bedrock.” In acknowledging these “essentials” (assumptions about human nature) that in some form are integral, yet often hidden, elements of any system of thought, Hoffman saves his own dialectical constructivism from falling into dichotomous (constructivist vs. essentialist) thinking.     

Review Essay

Pastoral Psychology -     

Essay Review

RADHIKA HERZBERGER, Bhartrhari and the Buddhists. An essay in the development of fifth and sixth century Indian thought. Dordrecht, Boston, Lancaster, Tokyo: D. Reidel Publishing Company, 1986. xxvi + 252 pp. DF1.145/$64/£40.25.     

Review Essay

Studies in East European Thought -     

Review Essay

Belief in God in an Age of Science , by John Polkinghorne
Genes, Genesis and God: Values and their Origins in Natural and Human History , by Holmes Rolston, III
The Genetic Gods: Evolution and Belief in Human Affairs , by John C. Avise     

Essay Review

Making human beings human: Bioecological perspectives on human development : Edited by U. Bronfenbrenner Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. 2004. Pp. 336. Paperback, $34.95. ISBN 0761927123. Hardback, $74.95. ISBN 0761927115     

Essay Review

B. Russell, Foundations of logic 1903-05, The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell, Volume 4, Edited by Urquhart, A. with the assistance of Lewis, A. C. London and New York:Routledge, 1994, Hi+ 743 pp. £100     

Essay Review

D. GABBAY and F. GUENTHNER (eds.), Handbook of philosophical logic. Volume 1: Elements of classical logic. Dordrecht, Boston, and Lancaster: D. Reidel Publishing Company, 1983. xiv + 497 pp. Dfl225/$98.00.     

Essay Review

Stephen Read, Philosophie der Logik. Eine Einführung, übersetzt von Martin Suhr. Reinbek bei Hamburg:Rowohlt Taschenbuch Verlag GmbH, 1997. 312 pp, 26.90 DM (paper)

Peter Millican and Andy Clark (eds.), Machines and thought—the legacy of Alan Turing, I, Introduction by P. Millican. Oxford:Clarendon Press, 1996. 297 pp. £30.00. ISBN 0-19-823593-3

Roberto Pou and Peter M. Simons (eds.) Formal Ontology. Dordrecht:Kluwer, 1996. viii + 293 pp. DF1 220, $135, £99. ISBN 0792 34104x

Jaakko Hintikka, The principles of mathematics revisited. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1996. xii + 288. No price stated. ISBN 0 521 49692 6

Luis Vega Reñón, Una guia de historia de la logica. Madrid:Universidad Nacional de Educacion a Distancia, 1996. 271 pp. No price stated. ISBN 84 362 3372 7

Barry Smith, Austrian philosophy. The legacy of Franz Brentano. Chicago and La Salle, 111.:Open Court, 1994 (pbk 1996). xii + 381 pp. No price stated. ISBN 0 81260 9256 X

Hans Hahn, Gesammelte Abhandlungen, 3. Edited by L. Schmetterer and K. Sigmund. Vienna and New York:Springer, 1997.xiii + 581 pp. DM 198/Ös. 1386. ISBN 3 211 82781 1

Susan Haack, Deviant logic, fuzzy logic. Fuzzy logic, Beyond the formalism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996. xxvi+292pp. No price stated. ISBN 0 226 31133 3 (cloth)/311341 (pbk)