On Replacing the Ethical Principle of Autonomy With an Ethical Principle of Accordance |
| |
| Authors: | R. Rocco Cottone |
| |
| Affiliation: | Department of Counseling and Family Therapy, University of Missouri–St. Louis. |
| |
| Abstract: | The author defines and critiques the ethical principle of autonomy. As a concept, autonomy is most aligned with paradigms of counseling that focus on the individual as a psychological entity with moral agency. It is less consistent with frameworks that focus on relationships philosophically and in practice. Autonomy is paradoxical, because it is a consensually defined principle imposed on counseling practice while denying counselors a choice in its application. The author suggests accordance as an alternative ethical principle. Accordance is consistent with relational paradigms of practice and the other relationship‐focused ethical principles in counseling. Accordance fully contextualizes individual responsibility and choice. |
| |
| Keywords: | ethical principle autonomy paradigms systems theory social constructivism |
|
