Conditions of Cognitive Sanity and the Internalist Credo |
| |
| Authors: | Andrew D. Spear |
| |
| Affiliation: | Philosophy DepartmentGrand Valley State University |
| |
| Abstract: | BonJour has proposed background conditions on internalist justification, which Kornblith argues are inconsistent with a core internalist ‘credo’ – that subjects internally alike are justificationally alike – signaling the ‘death’ of internalism. The funeral arrangements are premature, though more systematic consideration of background conditions is needed. The majority of BonJour's conditions are not background conditions as their failure makes an epistemically relevant internal difference. This neutralizes Kornblith's criticisms and reveals how the proposed conditions are not departures from internalism. BonJour's background conditions are simply conditions, the credo remains intact, and Kornblith's objections do not spell problems for internalism, let alone death. |
| |
| Keywords: | |
|
|
