Conjoint Weber laws and additivity

This paper investigates the mathematical consequences of a number of related empirical laws, exemplified by

$\text{P}{}_{\mathrm{ax;by}}\text{= P(ξa)(ξx);(ξb)(ξy)}$

where a, x, b, y, and ξ are real numbers, and P_ax;by is the probability of choosing the two-dimensional object (a, x) in the set {(a, x), (b, y)}. A variety of results is derived showing that, in the presence of such laws, the class of feasible models for choice data is considerably reduced. In particular, it is shown that the above law, together with the “additive conjoint” form

$\text{P}{}_{\mathrm{ax;by}}\text{= F[l(a) + r(x), l(b) + r(y)]}$

(where F, l, and r are unspecified except for continuity and monotonicity properties), requires the choice probabilities to possess one of the following three analytic forms:

$\text{P}{}_{\mathrm{ax;by}}\text{= G}\text{a}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{+ δx}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{b}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{+ δy}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{, β ≠ 0}$

;

$\text{P}{}_{\mathrm{ax;by}}\text{= G(a}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{x}{}^{\mathrm{\gamma }}\text{/b}{}^{\mathrm{\beta }}\text{y}{}^{\mathrm{\gamma }}\text{), β + γ ≠ 0}$

;

$\text{P}{}_{\mathrm{ax;by}}\text{= Q}{}_0\text{(a/x, b/y)}$

.